International Workshops on Public Policy
6-8 July 2026, Ottawa · International Public Policy Association
Section 2: The governance of education quasi-markets. Policy tensions and regulatory challenges
Across a growing number of countries, education services are delivered through quasi-market arrangements where public and private subsidised provision coexist and user choice plays a central role. In some contexts, mixed-provision schemes can be traced back to the creation of modern education systems, as the establishment of public systems of schooling did not necessarily entail the dismantling of private provision but often gave rise to some form of subsidisation (Ansell & Lindvall, 2021). In other countries, private subsidised enrolment has expanded considerably over the last decades in light of contemporary policy developments – most notably, the advent of market reforms. The expansion of user choice is a more recent but equally widespread phenomenon. Paralleling a decline in the role of residence in student-allocation processes, school-choice opportunities for parents have tended to increase, with most education systems allowing today for some degree of freedom of school choice (Musset, 2012; OECD, 2019).
Yet, despite the entrenched nature of education quasi-markets, recent years have been marked by an increase in their plurality and complexity. Alongside the diversification of the forms these arrangements take, expectations regarding the public and private interests they serve have also changed. Hence, while private subsidised providers have historically been expected to preserve a degree of privateness requiring certain autonomy and differentiation, such providers are increasingly expected to align with system-level goals and variously defined public interests, especially regarding equity objectives. Likewise, school-choice systems are increasingly expected to reconcile parental freedom with equity objectives, requiring some form of State intervention in student allocation (Zancajo et al., 2023).
This workshop is concerned with the tensions inherent in the coexistence of competing demands and expectations within contemporary education quasi-markets, particularly regarding the interplay between public and private forms of provision and spheres of interest. It builds on the premise that such diversity of expectations fundamentally constitutes a public policy challenge requiring an understanding of the varied origins of education quasi-market arrangements and the policy instruments underpinning them, as well as of the policy design choices through which different actors seek to govern and reform existing configurations. Accordingly, the workshop aims at facilitating a discussion along four venues of inquiry:
What are the conceptualisation and operationalisation challenges posed by the public and private provision categories in education? Particular attention will be given to how different definitions and measurements help capture and interpret the tensions posed by contemporary education quasi-markets.
How do mixed provision and school choice arrangements vary across contexts and over time, and what specific governance challenges stem from such different policy configurations? The workshop will examine the policy dilemmas associated with different institutional settlements between providers, families, and governments.
What regulatory approaches and policy instruments are used in different contexts to address emerging policy challenges? The workshop will pay particular attention to agenda-setting, policy formulation and policy implementation processes, examining how such dynamics shape the outcomes and impacts of different policy choices.
What values and political rationales underpin current policy debates around private provision and choice in education? The workshop will address how competing notions of social justice are negotiated in ongoing policy processes, and how such normative considerations influence the legitimacy and impact of reforms.
The workshop aims at stimulating a debate on the challenges posed by the study of education quasi-markets from a public policy perspective, bringing together researchers working across various contexts and stages of the policy cycle. We invite conceptual, empirical and methodological contributions. Empirical papers employing quantitative, qualitative or mixed-method approaches are welcome, including case studies and comparative analyses.
Listed references
Ansell, B.W., & Lindvall, J. (2021). Inward Conquest: The Political Origins of Modern Public Services. Cambridge University Press.
Musset, P. (2012). School Choice and Equity: Current Policies in OECD Countries and a Literature Review. OECD Publishing.
OECD. (2019). Balancing School Choice and Equity: An International Perspective Based on PISA_. OECD Publishing.
Zancajo, A., Fontdevila, C., & Verger, A. (2023). Markets in Education and School Segregation: Paths of Problematization and Reform. In V. Dupriez et al. (Eds.), Educational Markets and Segregation (pp. 81-101). Springer.
To submit a paper, please follow these steps:
- Go to the workshop page and click on “submit a paper for this workshop”.
Abstracts to be submitted by 20 January 2026.
Please note that this section of the workshop is fully on-site.
Please do not hesitate to get in touch with the section organisers for any questions or doubts:
Clara Fontdevila - Clara.Fontdevila@uab.cat
Adrián Zancajo - Adrian.Zancajo@uab.cat
Please consult the IWPP 2026 website for more information about the conference, including important dates, registration fees and the full list of workshops.
This section is organised in the context of Workshop T0801: Education policy: navigating new challenges and demands, chaired by Yusuf Sayed (University of Cambridge), Yifei Yan (University of Southampton), Clara Fontdevila (Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona) and Adrian Zancajo (Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona).
The workshop is premised on the notion that the multiplicity of expectations placed on education systems often create tensions, exposing the limits of existing governance arrangements. Such tensions call for analytical attention as to the policy ideas and instruments through which education stakeholders mediate among different goals and address interrelated challenges – as well as on the impacts of such arrangements from a social justice and equity perspective. To this end, the workshop is organised into two separate sections, each examining such tensions from a different angle. The first section will address the policy challenges derived from the combination of crises affecting the education field; while the second section will focus on the governance and regulation of education quasi-markets.
A detailed description of the workshop can be found in the IWPP 2026 website.